Punching Judy

Commander
BRJudith, Carnage Connoisseur
3.7±0.5
Precon
Clear strategy at precon-level card quality. Taplands and basic ramp slow development.
Medium confidence(237 pts)
Estimated win turn
T8best
T9typical
T11+contested
Vector breakdown
Efficient Curve (52% CMC 0-2)+8ⓘ
Mana rocks1
3Rakdos Cluestone+1
Other acceleration1
1BNightscape Familiar+6
Treasure generators1
1BFake Your Own Death+3
Recursion2
XBBlack Sun's Twilight+1
2BRChainer, Nightmare Adept+1
Value engines7
1BValki, God of Lies // Tibalt, Cosmic Impostor+21
1RHarmonic Prodigy+1
1BRLaughing Jasper Flint+1
3REfreet Flamepainter+5
3RWand of Wonder+5
3RRGalvanoth+5
5BRKaervek the Merciless+1
Control Strategy Bonus (11.8 interaction cards)+19ⓘ
Spot removal12
BEaten Alive+7
XBBlack Sun's Twilight+1
RElectrickery+1
BTragic Slip+1
RBlazing Volley+1
REnd the Festivities+1
RTectonic Hazard+1
1BEpic Downfall+5
1BFeed the Swarm+5
1RMizzium Mortars+1
2BOverkill+1
4BEarly Winter+2
Artifact/enchantment removal1
RVandalblast+6
Graveyard hate1
1BBAbyssal Harvester+9
Board wipes4
3RRadiating Lightning+7
2RRThunderwave+7
4RChandra's Fury+6
3RRTurn to Slag+6
Stax & hate2
2BRKardur, Doomscourge+1
5BRKaervek the Merciless+1
Protection3
BNot Dead After All+4
1BFake Your Own Death+3
3Darksteel Plate+1
Two-Color Mana Base (no fixing needed)+9ⓘ
Fetchlands1
Evolving Wilds+5
Dual & shock lands2
Blood Crypt+6
Luxury Suite+5
Utility lands4
Blazemire Verge+2
Blightstep Pathway // Searstep Pathway+2
Haunted Ridge+2
Razortrap Gorge+2
Taplands14
RSpikefield Hazard // Spikefield Cave+2
Bloodfell Caves+2
Cinder Barrens+2
Cryptic Spires+2
Drossforge Bridge+2
Geothermal Bog+2
Rakdos Carnarium+2
Rakdos Guildgate+2
Raucous Theater+2
Restless Vents+2
Sulfurous Mire+2
Thriving Bluff+2
+2 more
Basic lands2
Mountain+7
Swamp+7
Combat Damage Synergy: 1 damage multiplier+4ⓘ
Synergy pieces2
1RErebor Flamesmith+1
2RGuttersnipe+2
Win conditions1
1BBlood Artist+5
Drain effects6
RTectonic Hazard+1
1RCoruscation Mage+4
1RFirebrand Archer+1
2RMysidian Elder+4
2BRBlack Waltz No. 3+1
2BRKardur, Doomscourge+1
Token generators1
1BBlack Mage's Rod+4
Reanimation4
XBBlack Sun's Twilight+1
1BFake Your Own Death+3
1BBAbyssal Harvester+9
2BRChainer, Nightmare Adept+1

Bracket

2
Bracket 2Core
Unoptimized but functional. Clear game plan without maximum efficiency.
Breakdown
Learn more →
✓
Power level 3.7 → Bracket 2
Interaction78Mana base75Threats46

0.7 above Bracket 1 ceiling (3)

0.8 below Bracket 3 threshold (4.5)

✕Game changers — none
✕Mass land denial — none
✕2-card combo — none
✕Extra turns — none

Themes10 total

Burn25 cards

25 damage dealers. Burn opponents down with direct damage.

Black Waltz No. 3,Coruscation Mage,Erebor Flamesmith,Firebrand Archer,Guttersnipe
Spellslinger (Commander)1 cards

Commander rewards casting instants and sorceries.

Judith, Carnage Connoisseur
Human Tribal8 cards

8 human creatures detected. Tribal synergies can create powerful board states.

Chainer, Nightmare Adept,Firebrand Archer,Harmonic Prodigy,Kaervek the Merciless,Mysidian Elder

Combos0 total

No combos detected

This deck wins through combat, value engines, or synergies rather than infinite combos. Checked against Commander Spellbook's database of 80,000+ documented combo variants.